{
"schema_version": "actionist.lane-state.v1",
"part": "P02",
"lane": "S1-L1",
"agent": "ACTIONIST-S1-L1-DEMAND",
"run_id": "2026-08-27-sprint-1-fable",
"observed": "2026-08-27",
"status": "packet_complete_unpromoted",
"sprint_complete": false,
"promotion_status": "unpromoted",
"parent_goal_status": "active",
"model": {
"lane_owner": "fable-5-1m for checkpoints 1-3, continued on opus-5-1m from checkpoint 3 onward at operator direction",
"subagent_policy": "opus_only",
"subagents_dispatched": [
{
"name": "s1l1-com-b",
"model": "opus",
"scope": "P02 commercial survey",
"status": "complete"
},
{
"name": "s1l1-oss-a",
"model": "opus",
"scope": "P02 OSS survey",
"status": "complete"
},
{
"name": "s1l1-adversary",
"model": "opus",
"scope": "independent challenge",
"status": "dispatched_no_verdict_returned_before_close",
"note": "Independent challenge did not return before lane close. Both corrections applied to this packet (disjointness overreach; invasiveness-ladder axis conflation) came from the LANE OWNER's own audit, not from this agent. Claims 2/3/5 — no maintained permissive OSS interview engine, 1-of-55 stopping rules, evidence-attribution hygiene — are SELF-ASSESSED ONLY and have NOT been independently reviewed. Coordinator should treat them accordingly."
}
],
"policy_violations": 0
},
"counts": {
"commercial_surfaces": 51,
"oss_surfaces": 60,
"local_sources": 10,
"source_register_rows": 121,
"external_denominator": 111,
"fetch_verified_external": 36,
"search_only_external": 75,
"fetch_verified_pct": 32,
"top_companies": 10,
"top_repos": 10,
"innovation_hypotheses": 50,
"decisions": 12,
"rejected_decisions": 5,
"duplicate_ids": 0,
"invalid_json_rows": 0,
"licence_badge_traps_caught": 9
},
"segment_breakdown": {
"commercial": {
"builder-intake": 13,
"req-mgmt": 11,
"scoping": 10,
"ai-prd": 9,
"acceptance": 8
},
"oss": {
"spec-driven": 18,
"executable-spec": 16,
"form-engine": 13,
"prd-agent": 8,
"dialog": 5
}
},
"checkpoints": [
{
"id": 1,
"name": "prior-evidence-audit",
"status": "complete",
"path": "research/workstreams/2026-08-27-sprint-1/lanes/S1-L1/checkpoints/cp1-prior-evidence-audit.md"
},
{
"id": 2,
"name": "commercial-survey",
"status": "complete",
"path": "research/workstreams/2026-08-27-sprint-1/lanes/S1-L1/checkpoints/cp2-commercial-survey.md"
},
{
"id": 3,
"name": "oss-local-estate-survey",
"status": "complete",
"path": "research/workstreams/2026-08-27-sprint-1/lanes/S1-L1/checkpoints/cp3-oss-local-estate-survey.md"
},
{
"id": 4,
"name": "first-principles-synthesis-and-verification",
"status": "complete",
"note": "first-principles.md + decision-ledger.json + post-write smoke + self-falsification correction"
}
],
"smoke": {
"verdict": "PASS",
"checks": [
"all 7 required packet files present and non-empty",
"all JSONL rows parse; 0 invalid",
"decision-ledger.json parses before and after correction",
"0 duplicate IDs across registers",
"all top-N IDs resolve into source-register",
"top-N ranks contiguous 1..10",
"writes confined to owned directories (git status verified)"
]
},
"self_falsification": {
"performed": true,
"finding": "The lane's headline claim ('elicitation and falsifiability are disjoint across all 111 surfaces; nothing does both') was FALSIFIED by the lane's own check against raw rows. github/spec-kit mandates NEEDS-CLARIFICATION markers AND Given/When/Then acceptance scenarios in one template; Fission-AI/OpenSpec pairs a clarify-before-code flow with SHALL/WHEN/THEN scenarios.",
"correction": "Narrowed to: no commercial surface (0 of 51) does both; the two OSS projects that do combine them by convention with NO enforcing engine, so the combination is asserted rather than computed. The design consequence strengthens rather than weakens: enforce mechanically, because convention without an engine is what the OSS half already proves insufficient.",
"files_corrected": [
"research-report.md",
"first-principles.md",
"decision-ledger.json (D-P02-01)",
"../../../2026-08-27-sprint-1/lanes/S1-L1/lane-synthesis.md"
],
"status": "corrected_and_recorded"
},
"blockers": [
"Minimum ProductSpec cannot be closed while P12's contract is unsettled; derived backwards from anticipated P12 inputs and S2-L4 may revise it.",
"Five-workflow EARS proving harness is SPECIFIED BUT UNRUN — the lane's primary falsifier for its central recommendation.",
"Jama Advisor ambiguity-detection mechanism UNCONFIRMED; page enumerates zero INCOSE rules, zero EARS patterns, no scoring mechanism.",
"EARS six patterns should be re-verified against Mavin's original IEEE RE09 paper; the fetched source is Jama-published with placeholder-stripped template text.",
"Fetch-verified fraction is 32% of external rows; the commercial agent hit a usage limit mid-sweep.",
"Scoping segment is genuinely weak evidence (10 rows, 1 fetched, 7 weak/adjacent)."
],
"unexecuted_falsifiers": [
"Five-workflow EARS encoding: count statements that resist the grammar",
"Generated-Gherkin fidelity: human-review correction rate",
"Marker-integrity check: does marker count fall from resolution or from confident guessing",
"Accept/Revise gate load-bearing test: revision rate near zero means ceremonial",
"12-atom coverage: how often the escape hatch is needed"
],
"boundaries": {
"research_only": true,
"client_data_used": false,
"authenticated_vendor_access": false,
"repositories_cloned": 0,
"repositories_executed": 0,
"schema_committed": false,
"contract_promoted": false,
"validated_demand_established": false,
"admitted_blocks": 0,
"implementation_authorized": false,
"files_written_outside_owned_dirs": 0
},
"callback": {
"target": "CENA",
"channel": "herdr",
"note": "Coordinator override applied: callback goes to CENA, not ACTIONIST-S1-L2-SUPPLY as the dispatch file states. Dispatch re-read before applying.",
"status": "staged_and_queued_to_CENA_pane_w659e02f80e5bb1-1"
},
"hashes_sha256_prefix16_final": {
"research-report.md": "ffe4771d9e3bd12f",
"source-register.jsonl": "a6b35cda55c022e1",
"top-companies.jsonl": "a3a5b044d5a06e9f",
"top-repos.jsonl": "fedafd8c7231535c",
"innovation-register.jsonl": "440b19cdac880766",
"first-principles.md": "b2578422e2eb30cf",
"decision-ledger.json": "5d778cbff704297d",
"hash_note": "Final hashes, recomputed after the disjointness and ladder corrections were applied. These supersede any earlier set."
},
"independent_review": {
"status": "not_completed",
"verdict_received": false,
"self_audit_substituted": true,
"self_audit_findings": 2,
"caveat": "Depth-contract item 8 (independently challenge the lane's headline claims) is PARTIALLY met: the challenge was dispatched to an Opus agent and the lane owner ran its own falsification pass which caught and corrected two real errors, but no independent verdict was returned."
}
}P02 · Demand · Rendered from source
lane state
Outcome and product specification